I love a good bear market. And the way markets were trading made me think we were on the cusp of a new AI bear market. Now, I have seen a few, and I have made money from more than one, so puts me in rarefied company. I would love to be sure AI was a bear market now. Not only would it give a huge market cap to take aim at, it would also generate a huge range of auxiliary trades. I also know that bear markets are good for business - bearishness sells. But to really be able to bet big on bear markets, you need to find the price of something that is falling.
Back in the dot com days, the real trigger for its demise was the collapsing price of banner ads, which was the revenue driver for most internet stocks. With banner ad prices in freefall, all the recently listed IPOs business cases fell apart.
With the GFC, US house prices had actually started falling in 2007, BEFORE it all kicked off.
Before the bear market in iron ore and associated commodities, Chinese steel price actually started to fall.
Before the oil bear market in 2014, you had natural gas prices collapse years before.
Basically, you had signs of oversupply, and the market then went to work to remove the incentive to increase supply any further.
When I look at stocks like Oracle, they are mainly weakening on huge capex, and large debt levels. But, as yet, no signs of falling prices.
Looking across markets, there is cyclical weakness everywhere, probably driven by spiking energy prices - but this is different to a bear market. The cyclical weakness was probably exacerbated by the Blue Wave, but it certainly made the prospects of unending data centre growth seem even more unlikely.
What I have seen is huge shifts out of cyclicals and into defensives.
All of this movement has surprisingly little effect on the index, as it is mainly the moving on money around within equities, rather than the selling of equities. The S&P 500 has only just touched its 200MDA.
The weakness in Nvidia could be seen as a sign of trouble. But the bigger problem is does it signify anything more that the loss of the its CEO? What would be bearish is if GPU prices were falling.
There is no live GPU price but DRAM prices remain oddly strong.
And even odder, if I look at the S&P 500 versus gold, it would probably say everything is fine these days. Last year it was breaking higher, but now S&P vs gold is looking more bullish for S&P 500 than anything else.
Likewise, SPX/TLT tends to flatline before a major deflationary event. 2006 for GFC, 2014 for the shale bust, and even before Covid.
Today’s Anthropic IPO still shows that investors are putting money to work in the AI space. What I am saying, is that this COULD be the beginning of an AI bust, or it COULD just be another bog standard slowdown. I have in my career confused a slowdown with the end of an investment boom, and it makes for extremely painful shorting. And this is particularly a risk now, with oil prices having dropped this month. If they keep falling, expect a shift back into cyclicals
2022 also looked liked the end of the AI trade, but took off in 2023, as oil prices eased. What I am looking for is a sign that AI is trade is really over, and just not hated. Because in my experience, better shorts are finding a loved industry were fundamentals are falling apart but no one has noticed. I have still not quite found that with AI.





















